Apparently I'm in the minority here, but I thought it was one of the worst movies I've ever seen. It was exactly the same plot as Dances with Wolves with some cool visual effects. They dragged everything out so much that I was even begging for the fight scenes to end. They were so long it wasn't even entertaining anymore.
That and the giant hippie smurfs were so smugly self-righteous that I wanted to see the humans wipe them all out.
Gotta give ya credit, that was awesome.
However, I was at work at 7am, finished work and got to the theater at 8pm waited in line 'til midnight. They messed up the projector (gave us free tickets for it, though) and I fell asleep waiting 'til 12:45AM waiting for the movie...I did not sleep a WINK during that movie. I didn't see a single cellphone light nor did I hear a single person say anything. Not hearing anything at a premier is actually pretty rare, usually after a couple hours in line people don't want to wait to add their two cents to the movie. What was even crazier is when I saw the movie again a few days later at a regular showing the theater was packed and had the same result. I do not think it's going to have the same appeal as an at-home DVD, I think for 2009 Sherlock Holmes takes that awards (as movie that is GOING to be a good DVD) It was great in the theater because it's so immersive, it really makes you feel like you're in another world, and I'm actually considering going to see it a third time. It's never going to be nearly as good once it's out of the theater.